The Truth About Detroit’s Bankruptcy


Hi, everybody. It’s Stefan Molyneux from Freedomain
Radio. I hope you’re doing well. Let’s get to Motor City and try and figure out why the
Thelma & Louise basket case known as Detroit is currently sailing off the fiscal cliff.
This is the truth about Detroit’s bankruptcy. Ooh, let’s look at the crater, the smoking
crater known as Detroit’s finances. Estimated $18 to $20 billion in debt and unfunded liabilities,
that’s about $25,000 to $28, 500 for every man, woman, and child in Detroit or about
18 times to 20 times the existing budget. It’s almost $3 billion in general government
debt, $5.9 billion in Detroit Water and Sewage Department debt, $3.5 billion in unfunded
pension liabilities, $5.7 in unfunded retiree health care liabilities and they owe money
to more than 100,000 creditors, recently offered about 10 cents on the dollar but was not allowed
to. Over 23,500 city retirees are presently in danger of losing their benefits and bondholders
may be left with only pennies on the dollar. The majority of Detroit’s debt is accountable
for by public sector salaries and pensions. Thirty-eight percent of the city’s present
budget is being spent on legacy costs such as pensions and debt services. It’s not really
providing services to existing city residents but rather pensions to retired. This is a common factor and we’re going to
talk about this at the end of the presentation. This is monstrous and everywhere. Just look
at CalPERS in California, it’s the same kind of deal. Politicians don’t want public sector
workers going on strike and so instead of offering them raises in the here and now which
would require that they borrow or pay taxes — so I guess they don’t have the individual
ability to print money like the monopoly generating type, whatever you want into your bank account
federal reserve — so instead of offering them raises in the here and now which they’d
have to fund, they offer them very generous health and pension retirement benefits way
down the road, 20, 30 years down the road. Hey, look, we’re not even going to be in office
anymore. Let’s promise them whatever we want and whatever they want 30 years down the road.
This is all coming home to roost now which is really quite tragic. What has happened to the population? Well,
it’s been a kind of slow, disintegrating neutron bomb in Detroit. The decline of the car industry,
evaporation of manufacturing jobs, high tax rates, deplorable public schools and increasing
crime rates have led to many families moving away, families of a particular race which
we will talk about in a sec. Did you know, at one point, Detroit was the
fourth largest city and with Motown about the third loudest in the United States? But
over the course of the last 60 years, the population has decreased by about 61%, really
quite astounding. So almost two million people in 1950 down to 700,000 today of which about
nine are working. So it seems just the year 2000 over the last 13 years, the population
has fallen by 28%. A fraction of Detroit’s revenues, a graph
here, is going to debt. Pensions and retiree healthcare goes from 30% up to 2017 is the
estimated to about 65% of the revenues are going to people who aren’t even working or
providing services anymore. Completely unsustainable and it’s going to collapse the American economy. Detroit population, this slide to know where,
from 1.8 million in change in 1950, 700,000 now or it’s 2012. It recently filed for Chapter 9 Bankruptcy
protection in federal court that has been denied. It is becoming the largest bankruptcy
in the history of the United States and the largest public sector bankruptcy. I mean, this simple bankruptcy is fairly and
frequent compared to the $1.2 million personal and business bankruptcies filed in 2012 including
Detroit’s, there would have been 36 bankruptcies this 2010. Before that, pretty rare. No municipal bankruptcy has ever resulted
in involuntary cuts to retiree benefits. Now, I don’t know if you knew this one; if a private
company goes bankrupt, there is a government program called the Pension Benefit Guarantee
Corporation. It intervenes and provides a minimal level of benefits to anyone who’s
lost some of their retirement benefits, but it doesn’t back public sector pensions. So they met a few such Chapter 9 cases since
the Bankruptcy Act was amended in 1934 to include municipalities, but there’s not a
lot of precedent. And because there are so many creditors in Detroit, it’s going to be
quite a complicated technical wrangle going ahead. On the plus side, at least we have a legal
system which incentivize lawyers to minimize expenses and time consumed — no, wait. Sorry.
Opposite land got me again. Now, this is a domino. This is going to be
the first of many big bankruptcies. Chicago is in a similar situation. Unfunded pension
liabilities are the storm clouds gathering that are going to strike dead the economic
productivity of all major cities in the west. Eventually, it’s going to wind its way up
the courts. Supreme Court is likely to be involved in how to deal with this kind of
stuff. Now, there’s a legal and traditional battle
underway attempting to block bankruptcy from proceeding right now that has succeeded. It’s
the retirees who don’t want this bankruptcy to proceed because they don’t want to not
get paid their retirement benefits. So I mean, the legality is, I guess, vaguely
interesting for those of you who like those of you who like those Gordian knots into feeding
lawyer sharks, but the reality is no amount of lawyers can change the fundamental mathematics
that Detroit is insolvent. No amount of secular lawyers hurling briefs at each other is going
to change mathematics. Now, when a company goes bankrupt, in Chapter
11 it gets restructured. The Board gets fired usually. People move in and the whole company
gets restructured but in Chapter 9, this doesn’t happen. So you can wipe out some debt, but
the underlying issues of corruption and mismanagement and shrinking population and unfunded liabilities
are going to remain. So just something to notice. Let’s look at the employment situation. Oh,
my Lord, 1950 to 2011, of course, the population has shrunk completely. What has really happened
is there were about almost 300,000 manufacturing jobs in Detroit. Ask your grandparents. They
used to make a lot of cars there. Now, there are less than 27,000. Is it the $1500 per car that is required to
pay off the union thugs? I don’t know. Is it increased to health and safety regulations,
environmental regulations, which are kind of misnamed, just a bunch of government control
and bureaucrats strangling all entrepreneurs and productivity of the economy? Did you know that if regulations, federal
regulations had remained the same, which — and it wasn’t like the economy was unregulated
in 1949 — if federal regulations have remained the same, America would be many times richer
now instead of having a GDP of $15 trillion a year, it would be about $53 trillion a year.
Isn’t that astounding? With three to four times the amount of wealth,
would you not be able to solve pretty much all the environmental and poverty-related
problems? Of course, we would but we handed that power over to the government and look
what happened. So even between December 2000 and December
2010, 48% of the manufacturing jobs in the State of Michigan were lost. The unemployment rate went down from a peak
of 27.8% in December of 2009 when General Motors and the Chrysler Group were going through
their won bankruptcies. It’s still at 16.3%, nearly twice Michigan statewide average. The unemployment rate has gone down, but is
that just because people are leaving? It’s like I bet you they were a far fewer rats
on the Titanic just before it went down, but that doesn’t mean that they’d solve their
rat problem. So employment in Detroit, as you can see,
is just collapsing down from 2000 to 2013. Unemployment rate way up and then down slightly,
of course, partly because of the fed’s endless bloating stimulus, blood burning package of
fiat currency injections into the economy. Oh, catastrophic. In 1960, the City of Detroit
had the highest per capita income in the entire nation. Not a lot of people know this. In
the post-war period in America, in a mere 14 years, the poverty rate was cut in half.
Then the Welfare State came in and the decline stopped. We have solved problems of poverty
or at least voluntary poverty. It could have been solved generations ago, but again we
turned our power over to the State and look what happened. The average per capita income in the US currently
is $42,693. In Michigan, $37,497. In Detroit, $15,261. What a slow multigenerational rut
has occurred there. Nationwide poverty rate for the US is 12.6%,
pretty much exactly where it was when the welfare programs came in in the 1960s. In
Michigan, it’s 12%. Citywide poverty rate of Detroit, 36.16%. Shocking, astounding,
catastrophic. In Detroit, over 116,000 children live in
poverty. This represents 60% of Detroit’s total job population. About 27% of the city’s
total pop, it’s a 64% increase, 64.7% to be precise, increase in child poverty within
the city since 1999. Just horrendous. Ah, with catastrophic economies come catastrophically
high taxes almost inevitably. Detroit charged as twice as much tax per capita. Its neighbor
cities’ tax rates are at or near state maximums. This just encourages, of course, more people
to leave. It’s the same thing that happened with the late Roman Empire. They could only
tax in cities, drove all the young people out of cities which meant they were fewer
young people particularly, of course, young men to conscript into the military, which
meant they had to pay for mercenaries to maintain the empire, which meant they had to raise
taxes even more and the city’s just driving more people, meaning they had to hire more
mercenaries. Virtually, they couldn’t pay the mercenaries. Their mercenaries came and
sacked Rome, and it depopulated from over a million to about 19,000 within less than
a generation. And we had 1000 years of the Dark Ages. Yay! Something to look forward
to. These high taxes don’t generate even close
enough revenue to cover the city’s bills. Detroit has accumulated $700 million in deficits
over the last seven years. They cover it by borrowing the annual revenues for about $1.1
billion. Of course, it spends almost 40% of its revenue on servicing those liabilities
which is paying interest on the debt. By 2017, this will be 65% and, of course, it spends
a massive percentage of its income paying people who aren’t working anymore. So not really much left for things like running
lights, filling potholes, or sending emergency services out in less than an hour. Property
taxes have plummeted in Detroit. The funds now comprise 13% of general fund revenues
compared to 48% to 77% in other cities. Money from the state and federal government normally
makes up their remainder in most cities. Of course, the state and federal governments
have no money. I love it when they say that the government is paying something. No, no,
no, no, no, no. The government is stealing from other people, usually the unborn in the
form of debt, usually from the poor in terms of the inflation caused by fiat currency printing
or in raising taxes. They have no money. The government has no
money. The government is a revolving door of guns and butter. Detroit has the highest property taxes among
big cities nationwide and relies on assessments that are seriously inflated. Many homes are
presently assessed more than ten times their current market values. Reading about a guy, his house is actually
worth about $35,000. He paid over $5,000 in property taxes because the city rated it so
high. Shrinking groups of neighborhoods are relied
upon to pay the bulk of the bills. General Motors, DTE Energy, Chrysler Group, Marathon
Petroleum and three local casinos paid almost 20% of all collected property taxes. Now, let’s say you’re in Detroit and you say,
“Hey, property tax assessment, way too high. My house isn’t worth that much at all.” Well,
you can come and ask them to reassess it, and we’ll get into why that’s such a challenge
in a moment. Nearly half of Detroit’s 305,000 properties just didn’t pay their property
taxes. Oh, what a shame. Over 30% are also delinquent on their 2011 bills. Of course, the people in the houses say, “Wait
a minute. I’m not getting any services. The schools are crap. The lights are broken. Potholes.
No emergency services. The firefighters don’t come or can’t even use their ladders. So why
should I pay my bills?” An estimated $131 million in property taxes
and fees have gone uncollected, 12% of Detroit’s general budget. I mean, that’s not going to
put that much of a dent in $18 to $20 billion worth of debt, but it’s worth mentioning.
Seventy-seven blocks had only one owner who paid taxes last year. Detroit’s delinquencies in taxes are so common.
Many owners have been permitted to keep their property even without paying taxes because
it’s even worse if they flee, then the city has to take over the properties and all of
the associated liabilities. They ignored about 40,000 delinquent properties last year and
overlooking an estimated 36,000 this year. One of the ways that you could escape your
property tax bill is to abandon your property and then buy it back from the city. Six hundred
properties in 2012 were repurchased by their owners, triple the number in 2010. It costs
approximately $6 million in unpaid taxes assuming that they ever would pay. But a guy who owed
$35,000 on his house sold it and then bought it back from the city for $5,000, not a bad
deal. So if you want to get a reassessment of your
property because it’s valued too high, you can — the Detroit Department that assesses
properties is also under heavy criticism for waste and corruption. Its two top officers
work only two days a week and each makes more than $100,000 per year. Ah, the Pacman that eats the future. Detroit
property taxes due and paid 2011, 68% collected and almost 32% delinquent. I mean, it’s a
little hard for a city that doesn’t pay its bills to demand that you pay your bills, right? Education, oh, my Lord! This is one of the
reasons why it’s become such a smoking crater is that it’s really hard to lure businesses
to a city where half the population is functionally illiterate. So the annual nationwide teacher’s
salary is 56,000 in change, Michigan teacher’s salary is 63,000. Ah, in Detroit, the average
teacher’s salary is $71,000 in change. Nationwide, America spends or rather taxpayers
in the future, children sold off to the international banksters, pay $10,469 per student each year.
In Michigan it’s $12,500 in change. In Detroit, total educational expenditures per student:
$14,659. Now, for those of you who understand how the
government works, does more spending result in higher quality or does more spending result
in lower quality? If you guessed the first, please go back and
study your libertarian economics. Whenever the government spends more, you get lower
quality. Detroit spends 40% more per student in educational expenditures each year and
pays teachers 26% more than the nationwide average. What are the results? Dum, dum, dum,
let’s see. Only 7% of the eighth grade students are grade-level proficient or better in reading.
If that wasn’t bad enough, only 4% scored highly enough to be rated proficient or better
in math. It is at least some consolation that those
who are on the city council running the budget are actually 0% proficient in math based upon
what they’ve been doing for the last, say, 50 or 60 years. In 2009, Detroit public schools
posted the worst scores on record in the test of students in large central US cities. In
2012, the nationwide high school graduation rate was 78%. Detroit’s high school graduation
rate was 65%, but at least they were graduating with between 3% and 7% proficiency in Math
and English. In 2012, the nationwide dropout rate was 3.4%. Detroit’s high school dropout
rate was 19%. Secretary of Education, Arne Duncan, has referred
to Detroit as “ground zero for education in this country.” It’s not quite true. It’s the
day after tomorrow for education in America. According to Detroit Regional Workforce Fund,
an astounding 47% of the residents of the City of Detroit are functionally illiterate.
In other words, they’re listening to what I’m saying, not understanding much of it but
really can’t read it. What does “functionally illiterate” mean?
Well, it means you can’t fill out basic forms like a job application. You can’t read prescription
labels, what’s on a bottle, how many you should take, and so on. On the plus side, at least the ratings for
American Idol are declining. Ah, property crimes. How much fun is it to
live in Detroit? Let’s find out. So your chances of becoming a victim of property crime are
as follows: nationwide, one in 34; New York City, one in 44; Detroit, one in 16, they’re
number one. Your chances of getting your vehicle stolen are as follows: nationwide, one in
436; New York City, one in 613; Detroit, one in 62. So in about 50 years, they’ve gone from making
cars to fundamentally taking cars. That’s the new economy of Detroit. Violent crime rates in Detroit, New York City
and nationwide; these are things like forced rape, murder — I don’t know why forced rape,
forcible is rape — murder and non-negligent manslaughter, armed robbery and aggravated
assaults including assault with a deadly weapon such as a public school. Your chances of becoming a victim of violent
crime are as follows: nationwide, one in 259; New York City, one in 126; Detroit, one in
46. Your chances of becoming a victim of a violent or property crime are: nationwide,
one in 30; New York City, one in 33; Detroit, one in 12. Violent crimes per 1,000 residents in Detroit,
Cleveland, Pittsburgh, St. Louis, Milwaukee. Yay! They have the tallest column of hell.
Average crime rate nationwide is 33 per 1,000 residents not counting voting. New York City
has a crime rate of 31 per 1,000 residents. Detroit has a crime rate of 84 per 1,000 residents,
one of the highest crime rates in America compared to all communities of all sizes. In 2007, I don’t think there were a lot of
fireworks for this, Detroit was named the most dangerous city in the country by the
Morgan Quitno Report. Detroit has consistently been listed among the most violent cities
in the United States since 1985. In 2012, Detroit had 411 murders breaking the tourist-friendly
one per day metric, a 9% increase from the previous year. The city had 377 murders in
2011, 327 in 2010. The murder rate is at a 40-year high. It is 11 times higher than that
of New York City. Annual increases in homicides combined with
a shrinking population have made Detroit competitive with New Orleans for the highest murder rate
in the nation with the one caveat that in Detroit, you’re much less likely to be either
murdered by voodoo or clubbed to death with a jazz trumpet. The city has faced many cases of arson each
year on Devil’s Night, the evening before Halloween. In 2009, the Detroit Fire Department
reported 119 fires of which 91 were classified as suspected arson just on this little time
period. The size of the police force in Detroit has
been cut by about 40% over the past decade. When you call the police in Detroit, it takes
them an average of 58 minutes to respond compared to a nationwide average of 11 minutes. Most police stations in Detroit are not closed
to the public for 16 hours a day. So during the off hours, residents wanting to report
crimes cannot speak face to face with an officer. Instead, they must call or go online to make
reports. Something like you go to the website and you type, “Dear Officer, there’s someone
in my house and ahhh!” If you have a webcam, that makes it even more dramatic. The Detroit Police Officers Association is
warning citizens and out-of-towners that they enter Detroit at their own risks, saying they
are grossly understaffed and unable to adequately protect the public. Today, police solved less
than 10% of the crimes that are committed in Detroit. It’s even lower when it comes
to the majority of crimes committed in Detroit which is by the City Council. Case clearance rates Detroit, Cleveland, Pittsburgh,
St. Louis, Milwaukee, they have the lowest bars of hell in this particular situation. Total functioning streetlights — you can
pause this if you want to read the numbers — 40% of the city’s streetlights don’t work,
cloaking the city in darkness and further enabling crime. One-third of Detroit’s 140
square miles is either vacant or derelict since 2008. Detroit has closed 210 of its
317 public parks. Private donations allowed the city to delay the planned closure of another
50 this year. This winter, the city often just had ten to
14 out of 36 ambulances in service. Some have over a quarter million miles in them. In March,
a group of corporate donors gave $8 million so the city could buy some more ambulances. In February, Detroit’s fire commissioners
told firefighters not to use hydraulic ladders except if there is an immediate threat to
life because they hadn’t been inspected in years. So if you’re in a high building like
if you’re high up in a building, please don’t smoke. Now, we have to talk about the racial divide
because this is one of the most significant aspects of the demographic change over the
past 50 or 60 years in Detroit. Now, of course, in the late 1960s, there were a lot of racial
tensions in the US, all completely solved, as we can see from the recent Zimmerman case. In Detroit, in summer of 1967, about the worst
race riot the country had ever seen, one of the most violent open revolts of the 20th
century and lots of factors, of course, political, economic and social factors, growing police
abuse, economic inequality, black militancy, lack of affordable housing, urban renewal
projects and so on, rapid demographic change. Mayor Coleman Young, Detroit’s first black
mayor, wrote though, “The heaviest casualty was the city itself.” So what happened? On July 22, 1967, the Detroit
police raided an unlicensed bar in the center of the city’s oldest and poorest black neighborhood.
At the time of the raid, a party celebrating the return of two black servicemen from Vietnam
was in progress. Eighty-two people attending the party were arrested. During the raid,
an estimated crowd of 200 people gathered outside the bar in the belief that excessive
force had been used by the predominantly white police force. It’s not about the bottle thrown to the police
car. It ended with 43 people dead, almost 1,200 injured, and over 7,200 arrests. Approximately,
2,500 stores were looted and the total property damage was estimate to $32 million. Back then,
$32 million was real money. Because when you’re being oppressed by the man, the best way to
solve it is with a free TV. Until the April 1968, riots following the
death of Dr. Martin Luther King, the Detroit raised riots stood as the largest uprising
of the 1960s. So prior to the riots, Detroit had seen what had come to be known or what’s
now known as white flight or the mass movement of whites, especially middle class whites
from neighborhoods undergoing racial integration. During the 1950s, the white population of
Detroit declined by 23%. Correspondingly, the percentage of non-whites rose from 16.1%
to 29.1%. Sheer numbers of black population of Detroit increased from 303,000 to 487,000
during that decade. By 1967, the black population of Detroit stood
at an estimated 40% of the total population. Some of the neighborhoods were affected by
white flight than others, the 12th street neighborhood where rioting began in 1967.
In this neighborhood in 1940, the area was almost completely white, 98.7%. By 1950, the
area was 37.2% non-white. By 1960, only 3.8% of the area’s residents were white. So almost
a complete reversal in just 20 years. I mean, that’s really, really quite astounding. Sorry
— a little more than a decade. The first blacks did not move to the area
until 1947, 1948. A little more than a decade, it went from almost completely white to almost
completely non-white or almost completely black. Let’s look at some of these numbers. The dots
represent minorities and the dark colors here and the white represent the whites. So this
is 1950. You could see here 1960, 1980, 1970 is missing and 1990 and 2000. So that’s really quite an astonishing increase.
This is 2010. This is not unimportant, right? I mean, blacks are predominantly more likely
to be represented on the welfare rolls so they’re more expensive for a city, right?
So 3%, 4%, 5% of whites are on welfare; 26%, 27%, 28% of blacks are on welfare so it’s
much more expensive. Blacks generally for a variety of reasons have a lower income and
therefore pay fewer taxes. Blacks are, black youths in particular, are ten times more likely
to commit a violent crime than whites and Hispanic youths combined; therefore, more
expensive to patrol, to police, and so on. It’s a big challenge for a city to survive
with this sort of situation. It’s not, I mean, fundamentally, understand
it’s not a black issue. I mean, it’s a socialism issue. Socialism doesn’t work. I mean, the
amount of money that the Detroit City Council spent on these ridiculous boondoggles, trying
to stimulate economy, the amount of tax breaks they gave to people who ended up taking money
from the city but never actually developing any businesses, it’s just socialism. I mean
there weren’t a lot of blacks in the Soviet Union and that collapsed because communism
doesn’t work. Extreme socialism doesn’t work. So socialism fundamentally doesn’t work. It is, of course, primarily a democratic party
in state, local and national elections. According to a study released in the Bay Area City for
voting research, Detroit is the most liberal city in America measuring only the percentage
of city residents who voted for the Democratic Party. Democratic Party, the history of a pretty
racist party for some reason gets the allegiance of blacks. Beginning with its incorporation
in 1802, Detroit has had a total of 74 mayors. Last mayor from the Republican Party was Louis
Miriani who served from 1957 to 1962. So, Detroit elected its first black mayor,
Coleman Young, in 1973. He had a 20-year term as Detroit’s mayor. His tenure remains pretty
controversial. He is credited with integrating the municipal workforce and reforming the
police departments by its administration. So a large number of scandals and he was frequently
accused of having stoked the fires of racial divide for his own political gain. Again,
thank goodness that doesn’t happen anymore. So Mayor Coleman Young’s ally, William L.
Hart, served for 15 years as Detroit Police Chief before being indicted and convicted
for stealing $1.3 million in undercover police funds, sentenced to ten years imprisonment
and ordered to pay back the money. Deputy Chief of Police Kenneth Weiner, no relationship
to the “Don’t Tweet Your Meat” Weiner in New York, also a close associate of Young, was
charged and convicted in a separate case involving investment fraud and stealing $1.3 million
from the same fund. Charles Beckham, the City Worker and Sewage Director, was convicted
in 1984 for taking a bribe for a sledge-handling contract. It is heavily speculated that he
took the fall for Mayor Young who had also been named in association with the investigation. Young’s third term was marred by two federal
investigations that grew out of his efforts to direct city businesses to black-owned companies.
He underwent six federal investigations throughout his tenure, but he was never charged with
the crime, to be fair. All right, so let’s talk about the big picture
here. Detroit is a foreshadow. It is the day after tomorrow for US cities and US economy
as a whole. Municipalities are increasingly confronted with how to pay for promised pensions
and legacy costs. The Pew Center for the States in Washington estimated states public pension
plans across the US are underfunded by a whopping $1.4 trillion or were in 2010. I mean, that’s
almost 10% of the entire US economy. Chicago recently had its credit rating downgraded
because of a $19 billion unfunded pension liability that the rating service Moody’s
puts closer to $36 billion, Detroit $18 to $20 billion in debt. Chicago has almost twice
that just in unfunded pension liabilities. So these are promises made to pensioners that
the governments have not put money aside for. The governments, of course, they estimate,
“Oh, we’re going to get 6%, 7%, 8% return on investment,” which means they have to put
less money aside but that actually would be illegal for a private sector pension. You
couldn’t guess that much and since the recent financial collapse starting in 2008, you can’t
possibly get even close to that much. So it’s even worse. Cincinnati’s general obligation bonds were
also recently downgraded citing budgetary pressure from pension contributions. In Baltimore,
budget shortfalls are expected to run $745 million over ten years largely because of
the growth in pension costs. The Pew Center recently released a survey
showing that 61% of the nation’s largest cities had a gap of more than $217 billion in unfunded
pension and healthcare liabilities. Then we start to imagine anything but massive cuts
in the future for these unfunded liabilities. The financial resources are simply not there
but still we dream that somehow math is not a noose slowly tightening around our future. So the massive pressure that public pensions
are putting on municipal budgets, any move to ease these liabilities especially through
bankruptcy is being watched very carefully by state and municipal officials, union leaders,
retirees, and bond traders. Taxes can always be raised and services can
always be cut. Thus, bankruptcy may loom as the only choice left for struggling municipalities.
So here are some pensions and the unfunded aspect of this. This is as for the fiscal
year 2009. I’m not going to read all these off. You can pause if you want, but as you
can see, the funding levels are significantly low except in Washington, D.C. shockingly.
The belly of the beast, the heart of the monster has funding levels of 104%. Retiree healthcare, how much is that funded?
Well, the lower the lines, the worst things are. Even in Washington, D.C., the funding
level is only 49%. So hit the treadmill, old people, there’s not going to be much there
for you. Is there going to be a bailer? Well, Obama
promises in the past. It’s less likely to happen. It’s been a long line of bailouts,
of course, for Detroit. In the last five years under the veil of quantitative easing which
is really the diarrhea of fiat currency, one, two and three hundreds of billions of dollars
have been given to banks and other financial institutions that were deemed too big to fail.
Is Detroit with its population at 700,000 also too big to fail? Well, quantitative easing is being used to
inject $85 billion per month into the US economy which is the only reason it hasn’t collapsed
yet. That works out to $20 billion per week. So Detroit’s got a total debt of $18 to $20
billion. Will the federal government simply give Detroit one weeks’ worth of QE and let
them escape bankruptcy? It won’t solve the problems. It doesn’t increase the literacy
of the population. It doesn’t change the general issues of corruption and overspending. If you give — if people have financial problems
and you give them money, it only makes things worse in the long run. It’s like if you go
to some addicted gambler, some compulsive gambler, who’s run up a $20,000 toll of debt
and then you pay off his debt, what’s he going to do? He’s going to go, “Whoo-hoo! Let’s
start gambling even more.” It’s tragic but true. When talking about the GM and Chrysler bailouts
of ’08, ’09, President Obama did say that he refused to let Detroit go bankrupt. Oh,
what a megalomaniac and even say that “I refuse to let Detroit,” send them a check, President
Obama, with your own money. If you want to know what the future of the
US is going to look like, this is one of the reasons why we’re looking at the City of Detroit,
not just the US. It’s all over the west. Let’s look at the real numbers. According
to official numbers which means lies rubber stamped by the authority of the state, the
US national debt is close to $17 trillion. The US population is $310 million, $310 million.
So $53,000 of debt for every man, woman and child in the United States; that figure is
an estimated $30,000 higher per person than that of Detroit. If Detroit’s debt of $25,700 to $28,500 was
enough to put Detroit into bankruptcy, is the national debt of $53,000 per person enough
to put the US into bankruptcy? That being said, there is, to put it as nicely
as possible, substantial doubt as to whether the true size of the national debt in the
US is only $17 trillion. John Williams, no relationship to the composer, at shadowstats.com
calculated that the real national debt is actually an estimated $85 trillion. I actually
shaved my head so that I could start to talk about these numbers with my little finger
in my mouth. If John Williams’ estimate is to be divided
by the 310 million population of the US, $275,000 of debt for every man, woman and child in
the United States, that figures an estimated 10 times higher per person debt than that
of Detroit. Is that enough? Could nationwide debt that is proportionately
ten times higher than Detroit’s cause a national bankruptcy? Of course it will. It’s inevitable.
To make things even worse, the Congressional Budget Office has calculated that when including
present unfunded liabilities, so these are promises the government has made that they
don’t have enough money to pay for in the future, the national debt is about $202 trillion.
Mad. That’s about $650,000 for every man, woman and child in the United States. So if you count those people who are on welfare,
those people who are retired, those people who aren’t working, those people who are children,
those people who are in school, those people who’ve given up looking for work, those people
who aren’t employed, I think in the US, it’s you and you and that’s about it. You too are
totally going to get it in the shorts. I mean, you can certainly view this as an
economically better state than Detroit, but is it 25 times stronger? And while Republicans
claim to be against this kind of stimulus spending, they’re entirely fourth when it
comes to the military and industrial complex in military spending. Republicans love to
spend money on the military and then claim than it’s not welfare for the rich which,
of course, it is welfare for the rich plus evil is the military industrial complex but
that’s counter to this economic activity. Stealing money from people in order to spend
money on blowing shit up overseas and sometimes domestically is considered to be economic
activity that is productive because we live in the matrix of the state where up is down
and black is white. Can a national bankruptcy possibly be avoided?
Well, of course, what’s going to happen most likely as I predicted for many years is that
the government is going to turn on the dependent classes both the rich and the poor and suddenly
demonize them and use that reprogramming of the national delusions, called a national
dialogue to say that now we have to all pull together and we have to get on our butts and
we have to stop working and they’re just going to start cutting benefits while demonizing
the rich and poor who depend on those benefits. So where are we going? Well, of course, we
are going into a financial haul just like all empires beforehand, just like a statism
grows. It’s important to remember, of course, that America started it as an experiment in
the very smallest, tiniest government that could be imagined and it has now grown into
the very largest, most powerful, and most destructive government that the world has
ever seen with the capacity to destroy human and all life, in fact, on the planet many
times over. This is quite instructive. Small governments
generate economic growth. The economic growth is then used as collateral by these governments
to borrow and bribe the population in return for votes while deferring the cost of that
bribery to future generations who really get it in the shorts. So whenever you have a government, the fuel
of the free market creates a sort of delayed fuse, supernova status explosion in the future.
And this is why I would invite you to imagine, just picture, just come with me on a journey,
journey, journey. Just imagine the possibility of running a society without a state. Then
we don’t have to worry about economic growth being used to fuel inevitable fascism down
the road. We don’t have to worry about our freedoms being used as nooses slipping around
the necks of the unborn. I know it sounds crazy. Of course, we’ve always
had governments. Ah, so what? Who cares? We always had slavery until we didn’t, right?
We always had feudalism until we didn’t. So it’s not inevitable that these prehistoric
monstrous hierarchies that really come out of the primitive infancy of our species need
to direct the complex economic lives of billions of people around the world. It’s possible. It’s possible. If things were
better when the government was smaller, let’s just keep going until it’s gone. I mean, you
don’t want to reduce cancer particularly when reducing it makes it grow back faster later.
Just get rid of it completely. This is Stefan Molyneux for Freedomain Radio.
Thank you so much for watching. Good luck, Detroit.




Comments
  1. People don’t be so naive, this man is not even an American and probably don’t even live in Detroit so how in the hell would know anything about the city, other than what he has read. Discrimination, racism, poor neighborhoods housing and employment is what caused the problems in Detroit, and if you are not going to help and support the city, don’t make silly racist comments.

  2. It's naïve and unrealistic to believe that breed is not an important factor in the recovery of the Russian people from unlimited Progressive rule during the period 1917–1991. Suppose that the Russians were a low IQ and high savagery people like America's Africans. (In other words, suppose that they were African Americans.) Then most of Russia today would be very much like Detroit, and the south and west sides of Chicago, and other areas of the USA where a majority of people are descended directly from west Africans. The latter group of people do not live under a government of unlimited Progressivism, yet vice and squalor are their revealed preferences, just as if they were living under the progressive despotism of Venezuela. So the recovery of the Russians from a system imposed by activists among whom the Jews were greatly overrepresented has been a function not only of economic system but also of GENOME. Likewise, it's not true that the problem with Detroit is fundamentally "a socialism issue" (27:17)— unless we admit that socialism is a leading reason for the large numbers of Africans in Detroit.

    It's by the way that Jews were greatly overrepresented among the Fascists of Italy until the late 1930's when the Hitlerists had them driven from power. And it's no secret that the decay of America's cities and the advance of Progressivism is directly correlated with the influx of Jews.

  3. Oh my God. Who the fuck cares. Another white man talking about black problems. The underlying tone of your videos Stephen are hate, white superiority, colored people a problem. Talk about your own white problems and how smart you are. Races need to be separated again like we all were at one time. And stay the fuck out of our business, off our land, away from our women and men. Let us be.

  4. I live in the Detroit area and lived in the D for 10 years. Have seen shoot outs and dead bodies in empty fields with wild dogs ripping them apart. My friend was a paramedic in the D and told me that they look for vultures circling in the sky to find dead bodies. Detroits demise was multi-factorial ( offshoring plants, highway , Northland Mall, large ghetto population) but I think the biggest problem was King Coleman The Racist Mayor and the Demonrat party pushing socialism in the early 60's.

  5. ……..a mere 4 hour trek to the west is Chicago……Chicago can you hear Detroit coming?
    Probably not……because Detroit is already there. The next sound you will hear though…..is the Komatsu D575A.

  6. African Americans have been Bamboozled by Democrats and after Obama failed them after filling them with lies the left needs new illiterate blood hence the illegals. They look at getting food stamps as heaven sent, Mexico and its leaders give nothing so getting money for nothing is streets of gold. That is the reason they (The Democrats) do not care if we know they value the illegal more than legal citizens. Plus they can vote 10 times each, lol. They did in California.

  7. The U.A.W suck greedy don't care about the company they gave imports a advantage i always wanted to work for a American company but i will never work for these guys they killed our beloved auto industry and Detroit.

  8. Single moms and that kind of crap are the RESULT of what happened. All those who are responsible for taking our manufacturing jobs should be put up a against a giant wall (use trumps wall) and shot because that's what they did to us.

  9. Learn to do whats right,not whats popular. Reverse axium, if msm supports or reports on it then the truth is usually the opposite. If msm ever liked trump i would no longer support him. See how easy that is?

  10. According to Stefan, blacks have a retarded IQ and therefore the reason for Detroit's desolate condition compared to other American cities, because it has the highest number and percentage of blacks of any American city. What else do you need to know?

  11. The richest city on the planet now in ruins in just a few decades. If you want to know the end result of democrat policies. Look a Detroit. I’m not advocating to vote republican. They are not much better. Blacks in America were getting better and catching up with whites economically until LBJ and the great society. Johnson was the most evil president in American history

  12. AMERICA NEEDS TO PRINT ITS OWN MONEY AND HANG THE ROTHSCHILDS THE NATIONAL DEBT IS A FRAUD THIS IS THE LYNCH PIN OF UNSPEAKABLE EVILS – THE KEY TO THEIR POWER TO FURTHER THEIR AGENDA. DO NOT RECOGNIZE IT AS LEGIT, SEE IT FOR WHAT IT IS, A CRIME, THE POWER THEY DRAW FROM THIS IS THEN USED TO WAGE A WAR AGAINST YOU. WAKE UP!!

  13. All the people had to do when the jobs dried up was this thing called “move.”

    But no. Everybody hung around and went into poverty. Good job.

  14. As ex LEO. I feel as soon as they broke the law by coming into this America, MY country of choice, they became a criminal. Period.. I was a legal immigrant. Served as a Nam vet, became a US citizen then went to college and had a communication business w/15 service centers. Then became a LEO. I believe in law and order. AS Christ Jesus said. "If you break one law, you break them ALL". So true. You have to lie, steal/falsify documents. squat where you do not belong. take what is not yours. Etc., etc. Then you may become a gang member/pimp/drug dealer etc. What makes one think this is all good to go? Americans are not self protective enough until it becomes personal. ie: A loved one of your own gets hurt/raped etc. America get real! MAGA. Just because one was a child when they came here is irrelevant. they grow up to become lawless. their roots are in lawlessness!

  15. Obama’s pride and joy this is what lays ahead for the USA when crackhead clowns get elected to office. Obama 8 years of recession ,unemployment and a flood of immigrants.

  16. Melanin is now more valuable than ever! Climate change has likely been contributing to a steady decline in the U.S. birth rate, especially if you are of European extraction researchers said, predicting as many as 100,000 fewer babies born each year by the end of the century.Data shows the number of babies born drops in the eight to 10 months after a spate of days on which the average temperature exceeds 80°F (26.6 °C), according to research by the National Bureau of Economic Research, a non-partisan group based in Cambridge, Massachusetts.For men, exposure to extreme heat can negatively affect semen quality and testosterone, and in women it could have an impact on menstruation, ovulation and implantation of fertilized eggs.This is especially true for non-melanated populations. The study does not take into account the additional damage done by increasing UVB/UVC radiation levels on female fertility and male sperm motility. Note:- A 57% decline in sperm concentration occurred over a 38-year period ending in 2011 among men from North America, Europe, Australia and New Zealand.The EPA has taken down ALL information regarding the UV Index and UV radiation warning system.

  17. You can help solve Detroits problems by copying the Rainbow Government of South Africa, Nelson Mandelas ANC party. Steal white owned farms, because those whites stole the land from somebody else , kick out white US farmers and Redistribute the land to poor blacks.

  18. It's heartbreaking to see Detroit today. Sadly, that same decline is also here in St. Louis, Mo. Two of my daughters teach school in depressed cities. One district furnishes each student with a free laptop in middle-school. Many students are careless and rough with their laptop. Why?? Because their parent(s) didn't have to pay for it. Every week my daughter sees laptops being thrown in the hallway. As long as our government continues giving out free handouts, lazy people have no reason to be responsible and become self-sufficient. Being on the dole is far easier than working.

  19. Maybe it would be interesting to do an update for 2018. Or maybe more interestingly one at the end of Trump's term. See if he will have made America great again.

  20. http://www.savethefueltax.org/

    Please vote NO next August to defeat the next Detroit tax increase. It will all go the rich if it passes.

  21. Well, so much for capitalism, or is it communism? I could never tell. But let's blame the blacks as usual. THAT ALWAYS WORKS!

  22. money should represent value made . In some cases people follow money like it makes value. Think! even sometimes Think!

  23. The soft bigotry of low expectations mixed with misplaced compassion is a whirlpool human waste ominously circling the drain. Welcome to present say America. Left/right matters not. They are the jackboots of the Rothschild's et al. fractional reserve banking cartel. You cannot spend your way out of debt but you can very very effectively enslave a nation by debasing its currency.

  24. SOLACE AND COMFORT

    Donors: Esther Ballestrino de Careaga, George Rudolph Berrian, Celsus John Brown, Sebastian J. Cacaci, Dorothy May Day, Basil Joseph Dzikas, Ignacio Ellacuría, S.J., Luís Espinal Camps, S.J., Michael Goldstein, Rev Trey Hegar, Jessica Johansson, Amando López, S.J., Joaquín López y López, S.J., Tarsicio Macias, Peter Kerron Mannion, Ignacio Martín-Baró, S.J., Arthur C. Mayer Jr., Rosario Raphael Mazza, William J. McCarthy Jr., Harvey Bernard Milk, Segundo Montes, S.J., George P. Moore, Juan Ramón Moreno, S.J., Elliot Noss, Ross Rader, George P. Reilly, Charles Louis Rommel, Jason Silverstein, Davinder Singh, Jody Stocks, David Woroch, Rev Lori Wunder

    677 Stableway Road
    Pike Road, Alabama 36064-2745
    Catherine Anne Howieson, Daniel E. Howieson, Darrell Howieson, Devlin Q. Howieson, Douglas Howieson, Eva Howieson, Regina Howieson
    334-271-0055

    4307 Desert Springs Trail
    Sierra Vista, Arizona 85635-3665
    Christopher David Monken, Geoffrey Monken, George N. Monken [email protected] Lisa Charmaine Monken, Rebbecca K. Monken, Vicki Monken
    520-220-7150

    Larry's Place-ExCon Shelter, founded by Charles J. Boulanger (1915-1999) 087-09-7431 660 West 178th Street, apartment 6D, New York, New York 10033-6543 212-927-3641 and Elizabeth T. Boulanger/Betty Boulanger (1918-2014)
    for
    Lawrence K. Boulanger/Lawrence Boulanger/Larry Boulanger [email protected] (1951-)
    and
    Carla M. Boulanger, 209 Ridgevale Lane, Pleasant Hill, California 94523-3504 925-464-7603
    and
    Jeanette L. Boulanger/Jeanette Boulanger
    and
    Martin D. Boulanger/Martin Boulanger/Marty Boulanger
    and
    Michael Patrick Boulanger/Michael P. Boulanger/Michael Boulanger/Mike Boulanger
    and
    sister-in-law Terry Boulanger/Therese E. Boulanger/Theresa E. Boulanger [email protected] 212-567-5341 83 Park Terrace, apartment 2C, New York, New York 10034-1336 212-567-5759
    and
    Suzanne M. Boulanger née O’Neill, 501 East 234th Street, apartment 3H, Bronx, New York 10470-2416 718-798-2180

    1531 Hilltop Drive
    Longmont, Colorado 80504-3012
    Braden W. Olson, Harlan Lee Olson, Jane Olson, Janelle Olson, Juanita Olson, Kara Olson, Kirk Olson, Suzanna Yudico Olson
    303-776-2314

    111 Woodbury Place
    Decatur, Georgia 30030-2966
    Brent Woodruff Crabb [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Holly Camille Crabb [email protected]
    303-733-7906 512-293-2311

    1612 Stonebrooke Drive
    Edwardsville, Illinois 62025-4296
    Barbara J. Duvall, Bruce B. Duvall, John B. Duvall, Kate M. Duvall @kmdvl06, Sarah Duvall
    618-659-2491

    7332 Bramblewood Lane
    Indianapolis, Indiana 46254-9713
    and
    590 West 174th Street, New York, New York 10033-8236
    Ignacio M. Larrinua, Mary Theresa Wolf, Esq.
    317-293-6872 317-490-6950

    2960 19th Avenue
    Marion, Iowa 52302-1409
    and
    2219 Williams Boulevard, S.W.
    Cedar Rapids, Iowa 52404-1544
    and
    Post Office Box 184
    Marion, Iowa 52302-0184
    and
    Post Office Box 2072
    Cedar Rapids, Iowa 52406-2072
    April Lynn Bast/April L. Bast/April Bast, Brian Daniel Bast/Brian D. Bast/Brian Bast, Crys Rae Bast/Crys R. Bast/Crys Bast, Crystal Rae Bast/Crystal R. Bast/Crystal Bast, Gerald Eugene Bast/Gerald E. Bast/Gerald Bast/Jerry Eugene Bast/Jerry E. Bast/Jerry Bast, Meghan Bast, Nancy Lee Bast/Nancy L. Bast/Nancy Bast, Nicholas Alexander Bast/Nicholas A. Bast/Nicholas Bast/Nick A. Bast/Nick Bast [email protected] , [email protected]
    319-373-1974 319-373-3021

    318 2nd Avenue N.W.
    Mount Vernon, Iowa 52314-1305
    Evelyn Johansen, Kay Marie Johansen, Esq./Kay M. Johansen, Esq./Kay Osterberg, Esq., Jordan Leitl-Wagnitz, Kay A. Reisner, Dr. Dave Osterberg, Sr./Dr. David Earl Osterberg, Sr./Dr. David E. Osterberg, Sr./Dr. David Osterberg, Sr. [email protected] , Jessica Osterberg, Micah Osterberg, Shawna Osterberg
    and
    Iowa Public Policy Project
    20 East Market Street
    Iowa City, Iowa 52245 http://www.iowapolicyproject.org/
    319-338-0773 319-895-8731

    524 North Pine Street
    Olathe, Kansas 66061-2526
    Amber Cox, Christopher Cox, Dawna Cox, Ida Cox, Jane Cox, Jarrott P. Cox who runs Cox Vending from home, Joyce S. Cox, Lynnette R. Cox aka Lynnette Rae Roth, Sarah Teresa Lee Cox, Susan L. Cox, Vivian Minor
    913-764-1789

    Fitzgerald Hall
    3500 Lindell Boulevard
    St. Louis, Missouri 63103-1021
    Rev Professor Paul Garcia Gonzalez [email protected]
    314-977-5019

    11330 Taylor Street
    Omaha, Nebraska 68164-2341
    Jeremy Michael Bender, Tavarius Bender, Teresa A. Bender

    576 Ludlow Station Road
    Asbury, New Jersey 08802-1117
    Catherine Rose Berrian, George E. Berrian, Nancy Berrian-Dixon, David L. Dixon, Viola Dixon [email protected]
    972-775-4773 973-537-7172 908-537-7172

    7410 Rice Road
    Auburn, New York 13021-9096
    Matthew Bannister, Robert Paul Bannister, Jr., Wendy M. Bannister
    315-252-9246

    874 72nd Street
    Brooklyn, New York 11228-1050
    and
    127 Utica Avenue
    Brooklyn, New York 11213-2338
    and
    874 72nd Street
    Brooklyn, New York 11228-1050
    and
    179 Wilson Avenue
    Brooklyn, New York 11237-3742
    and
    301 Gold Street, Brooklyn, New York 11201-3003
    James E. Murray/James Murray/J.E. Murray/Jim Murray, James P. Murray, Kelly A. Murray, Linda Ann [email protected] , Kelly Ann Quinones [email protected]
    718-444-3102 and 718-680-6379

    47 East 129th Street
    New York, New York 10035-1134
    and
    211 West 141st Street
    New York, New York 10030-1707
    and
    276 West 151st Street, New York, New York 10039-2302
    Father Gregory C. Chisholm S.J./Father Gregory Chisholm S.J.
    212-281-2100

    1947 New York State Route 74
    Ticonderoga, New York 12883
    Ada S. Phelps, Stephen E. Phelps, Jr., M.A., CFRE [email protected] [email protected]
    518-503-5067

    10 Utah Place
    Athens, Ohio 45701-1456
    Bayley Newlen, Carl E. Newlen, Tristen Newlen
    740-249-9559

    2210 Howey Road
    Columbus, Ohio 43211-2040
    Christopher L. Bergheimer/Christopher Bergheimer/Chris Bergheimer/Chris L. Bergheimer/C.L. Bergheimer, Elizabeth Bergheimer née Hemingway, John William Bergheimer, Kelli Jo Bergheimer née Washer [email protected] /Kelli J. Reed/Kelli Reed/Kelli J. Washer [email protected] /Kelli Washer, Rachel Anne Bergheimer, Sarah B. Emerson, Kylie Amber Lev, April A. Reed, Casey Wesley Washer/Casey Washer [email protected] , Corey William Washer/Corey W. Washer/Corey Washer, Wesley Alan Washer/Wesley A. Washer/Wesley Washer
    614-210-1042 614-268-5919 614-327-7680 614-561-9248 614-732-4081

    John Carroll University
    1 John Carroll Boulevard
    University Heights, Ohio 44118-4581
    Father Gregory C. Chisholm S.J./Father Gregory Chisholm S.J., Dr. Joan M. Nuth, Ph.D. [email protected]
    212-281-2100 216-397-1678 216-397-1886 216-397-4294 888-335-6800 940-268-8788

    11930 Meadowdale Drive
    Meadows Place, Texas 77477-1713
    Patricia C. Baldwin, Robert H. Baldwin, Robert James Baldwin, Shannon A. Baldwin
    281-498-4078

    5691 W 5300 S
    Hooper, Utah 84315-9566
    Blaine C. Odenwalder, Brent C. Odenwalder, Clint Dean Odenwalder, Kevin Jay Odenwalder, Kristen Michelle Odenwalder, Laura Odenwalder, Lisa J. Odenwalder, Michelle Denise Odenwalder , Micky Sue Odenwalder/Micky S. Odenwalder/Micky Odenwalder [email protected], Rex C. Odenwalder, Scott Brent Odenwalder
    801-660-7028 801-985-9815

    424 South Washington Street, Suite 1a
    Alexandria, Virginia 22314-4153
    Dr. Gloria Morote, Ph.D., PLLC
    703-683-2695

    2941 Rosemary Lane
    Falls Church, Virginia 22042-1857
    Linda L. Clarke, Jerry C. Haggin
    703-641-0906

    Corporate Sponsors: American Friends Service Committee, Bastinado Brotherhood, Catholic Worker Movement (CWM), Contact Privacy Inc., Enom, Frijolero Centro Refugio DACA 'Fritz Haarmann', Hot-People, Ignatian Recrimination Nation, Larry's Place-ExCon Shelter, LaSallians, LDS Coprolith Project, Parents of Polycephalic Children, Polygender Alliance, Society for American Guilt, Society of Jesus (S.J.), Tucows, Welfare Families in Crisis

  25. Blacks have only contributed to the ruin of Detroit because mean racist whites haven`t provided enough free programs for them.

  26. Just bulldozer the entire city to the ground.
    And turn it into a huge park, or just open land, for car race, skating, and other sport activities.
    Nothing else can be done about it.
    Liberals, Democrats, and Black people ruined it.

  27. Deadtroit should be sold to China for a dollar. Let them make it a Chinese sovereign zone. I'll bet in a couple of years they will have that mess cleaned up.

  28. The most amazing thing about the "national debt" is since 1913 nothing of any values has ever been lent. It's all a ruse of fiat currency.

  29. Its the perfect opportunity for OCP (Omni Consumer Products) Buy out City Hall and turn cesspool Detroit into a private metropolis.
    Or what Apple bought out City Hall and turn Detroit into the first Privatized Metropolis using the Blockchain ledger and tokens to vote with. It would turn Detroit into the NEW AGE, BIG APPLE

  30. The truth is this – The Catholic Federal Empire, (primarily the Jesuit order) has laid to waste countries for their various ambitions. The United States of America is no exception. One of the key weapons of the Jesuits has always been the Negro. Not just the Negro, but the incredible work put into creating the hatred that exists between blacks and whites. The motto of the Jesuit order is "Order out of chaos."Their order – Our chaos." Oh Lucifer, son of the morning. How art thou cut down to the ground which didst weaken the nations." – earlychurchunderground.com

  31. Before being declared bankrupt, the black mayor of Detroit ordered a gold waste bin for his office. I'd say that it's the perfect metaphor for what happened.

  32. Detroit went from 90% White to 90% Black Three riots, rampant crime, brutal murders. The whites had to leave. Blacks running the place and populating the place led to African conditions.

  33. Why is it that every time things turned to shit . . . .it's always black people standing there yelling racism and it's white people's fault . . . . . When white people were the majority . Detroit was fine . . . . Blacks became the majority and this is Detroit now . . . . Does anybody see the difference . ??? . . . . It's not racism it's just a fact . . . . Has anybody noticed Detroit now looks a lot like Africa . . . . And that's the way the rest of America is going to look .. Under black leadership . . . . . . . Any were black people go they bring the attitude that if you disagree with anything they say or do . . , They label you as a racist . . . And then they want to tell the world how we owe them everything . . . . And then they want to turn everybody against the police by making all them out to be racist . . . So Blacks can run wild and not have to worry so much about the police . . . Thats why Blacks try so hard to make people hate the police . . . . . And like always black people never do anything wrong and it's always everybody else fault but there's . . . . Because they have the whole world down as being racist . . . . Because if you don't let them do anything they want to and just let them get by with it . . . They start yelling racism . . . . The problem isn't racism . . . . The problem is stupidity .

  34. I'm white and English and no doubt I'll be called racist for this but why is it that where ever you get predominantly black communities or countries you get violent crime, deterioration of areas and lower productivity. Until we address this elephant in the room we will never solve this issue.
    We can happily accept whites are most likely to be serial killers and that blacks are more successful at sport but speak uncomfortable truths that don't portray blacks in a good light and you are rounded upon. Helps no one and gets us no where it just turns communities in the West into 3rd world type ghettos.

  35. 1967 is when we moved – just as they were burning the car dealers down the street. We lived right smack dab in the middle of Detroit.

  36. It's just demographics. You can prove every city that was once 90+ percent white is now a shithole to live in the city. Now apply the cities of Chicago and LA to the ENTIRE COUNTRY, this is what America will look like with a white minority

  37. SEND THOSE STUPID LIBERALS INTO ONE OF THOSE CULTURALLY ENRICHED GHETTOS FOR A FEW NIGHTS WITHOUT PERSONAL SECURITY GUARDS , IT WILL BE A GOOD EDUCATION FOR THOSE IGNORANT JUDASES , THOSE HATING THEIR OWN RACE IDIOTS .. LIBERAL LEFT IS A INTELLECTUAL POISON

  38. It's called corporate greed by American companies who are going to other countries for cheaper labor and do not give a fuck about the American people simple as that.

  39. I live in North West Detroit and I use my car for work, delivery driver. I’ve had my catalytic converter stolen and my window broken. Between repair costs and time working lost, it’s cost me about $100 a month, over the year I’ve lived here. Crime here is no joke.

  40. Fun fact: Detroit was once considered one of America's most beautiful cities, owing to beautiful architecture, excellently designed park and street systems, as well as the city's wealth. Many American industrial cities were centers of wealth long before the welfare state existed. Part of why the most beautiful buildings predate the 1930's

  41. And to think that Detroit was the city that made it plain to one Japanese General that the US would easily win the war. That's when it was a white city.

  42. Due to wartime production Detroit's population peaked in about 1947. There was a decline by the time of the official census in 1950.

  43. The Democratic party is not socialist. It is a centrist party. The vast majority of Americans have no idea of the nature of a centrist party.There are scores of countries which are centrist and they are successful nation's with healthy, well educated populations that maintain a high quality of life unlike the US. America's biggest problem is mismanagement and corruption and a poorly educated populace. There is a growing underclass for whom there is no social or economic mobility. America biggest problem is stupid. Blame Democrats for debt? It doesn't matter. I'd say it's a team effort. Between Trump and Bush it's difficult to determine who will win the blue ribbon for creating debt. You guys picked a POTUS who has run many businesses into the ground and left countless people holding the bag and now he's in charge. Good fuckin luck!!!

  44. The future of all of America….companies moving to foreign countries not wanting to pay American workers since they can pay .65cents an hour in Mexico…has it brought the price of car's and other products down….hell no…The UAW is greatly to blame,they wanted wages and benefits that totaled about $80 per hour for every auto worker…bring back the auto manufacturing and put jobs out there starting at $15 an hour plus medical insurance and people will flood in…it can be done…Toyota has done it in Texas…Detroit can be fixed…it must or it will remain a cancer and only grow larger

  45. Look at Stockton California. Same thing. Look at the State of Illinois. Same thing. The obvious solution would be the same thing that happened to the big banks in 2009. TARP funds. The Federal Government gave $749 billion to the big banks. Those were private companies. Detroit is a public company.

  46. Well, is Detroit a sh*thole and unsafe, if so why?  WE CAN BLAME "THE GOVERNMENT," AS LOSERS OFTEN DO…  A DEMOCRAT MAYOR SINCE 1962, RIGHT!  What is the population of Detroit, lets check:  Blacks/African American is 79.1%;  White is 14.1%;  and Hispanic 7.6% – https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/detroitcitymichigan/PST045218  Oh, let's look at more stats: Detroit Public Schools: 93% Not Proficient in Reading; 96% Not Proficient in Math – https://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/terence-p-jeffrey/detroit-public-schools-93-not-proficient-reading-96-not-proficient  So, maybe these statistics tell a story?

  47. I would argue at least in this case increases in educational spending correlates with literecy rates compared to national average ie as the burden of educating the students goes up, it is a higher stress on the teacher and they would demand more money. Sadly I doubt there is anyway to keep up with the burden created mostly by the greed ignorance and fear filled reactions of people who never or no longer reside within this city.

  48. Decades of social dependancies , foster a mind set that in its self will take decades for the population to be weened off . This is happening in a lot of western countries that relied on industry. Cheaper imports, the environmental issues, people not wanting to do manual labor steered people away from thinking manufacturing was bad for us .
    Shamed into thinking your lower than low if you work with your hands .
    When all the unnecessary things we pay for run out i:e phones , loans insurance, drugs gambling lawyers divorce , drinking , on line gaming , tv subscription internet and many many more products that make nothing physically . But perpetually chip away at your already low salaries.Then they will have to turn to there hands to live as indeed there money will run out in the end .
    If your country produces little we can’t be all sales men selling a foreign product, you end up with a money go round with no money coming the other way instead you print money to sustain this ideal in the end you turn out like Detroit and there will be many more to follow all over the western world.
    There has to be an equilibrium .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *