Satisfying Answers on Socialism: An Open Letter to Destiny


[Spooky ambient sounds] [Karl Marx] Lucky Black Cat… [Marx] Lucky Black Cat… [Marx] Lucky Black Cat! [Magical sparkle sound] [Lucky Black Cat] Yes, Dear Leader. How may I serve you? [Marx] I need you to bring someone to the Dark Side. [Lucky Black Cat] You mean turn them against capitalism? Well, that’s what I’m trying to do for everyone. I’ve devoted my life— [Marx] I need you to convince the one they call “Destiny.” [Lucky Black Cat] Destiny? Oh, you mean the YouTuber and Twitch streamer. Yeah, I know Destiny! I like him, he’s like my favorite liberal. [Marx] Favorite liberal?!!!! [Lucky Black Cat] I only meant— [Marx] We do not have favorite liberals, just as we do not have favorite fascists! [Lucky Black Cat] Right, right. [Marx] Don’t you remember? Liberals get the bullet, too! [Lucky Black Cat] Sorry, Dear Leader, I forgot. [Marx] Make that mistake again and I’ll see to it you get the bullet. [Lucky Black Cat] Ok, so you want me to like make Destiny like a socialist? [Marx] Yes. He has hundreds of thousands of subscribers on Twitch and YouTube. If you bring him to the Dark Side, the influence will spread to the masses. [Lucky Black Cat] Ok, I guess I could make a response video to him, but I don’t know what to say. He seems pretty set in his pro-capitalist opinions. [Marx] Do not worry. I have a script prepared for you. I will beam it into your consciousness using that chip I installed in your brain. [Lucky Black Cat] Oh no, not — not the chip again. That really hurts. [Marx] Incoming in three… [Lucky Black Cat] Seriously, don’t. [Marx] …two… [Lucky Black Cat] Can’t you like, send it by email? [Marx] …one… [Lucky Black Cat] Or like print it? [Marx] Sending. [Lucky Black Cat] Aaggh! Aaaagggghh! Aaaaaaaagggghhhhhh! [Marx] Uh, send complete. Destiny! Hello, Destiny. I saw that video from The Serfs where you debate Professor Ben Burgis on socialism. I thought Ben did a really good job of defending his position, but I couldn’t help but notice that Ben’s answers seemed to leave you — – uh, how should I put this — unsatisfied. Although Ben and I can both call ourselves socialists, we’ve got very different takes on how socialism is defined. That means I can give very different set of answers to your question than the ones that Ben gave, and I believe you will find these answers more satisfying. Ben can’t satisfy you like I can, Destiny. No one can. [Opera song “Habanera” plays] I made myself pretty for you.
[Opera song “Habanera” plays] [Opera song “Habanera” plays] [Screeching sound from “Psycho”] So, you had four main concerns about socialism, or the socialist perspective, that you expressed in your debate with Ben: Now, these are all important, legit concerns, and in fact, they’re concerns I had back in the day. So I’m really glad you brought them up, and in this video, we’re gonna deal with them one by one. So, enough long talk, let’s run this. [Marx] Destiny… Destiny… Pledge yourself to me, Destiny…. Become… my disciple. So, Destiny, it’s clear you don’t like the moral judgment that is sometimes placed on capitalists. Like I would argue that it’s probably not like that huge of a moral wrong. And then you get into these weird areas where people are just saying like fuck all rich people and fuck all landlords and fuck all capitalists! Well like what the fuck? Alright, so, I try not to put moral blame on capitalists, and I think Ben would agree. The problem is not with capitalists as people; the problem is with their social role. Some of my comrades might want to guillotine me for what I’m about to say, but… (Whispering)
I actually know a couple of people who used to be capitalists, and… (Whispering)
I think they’re both really kind and generous and just really good people. Is it immoral to exploit workers and take their surplus value ? Well, yes, I’d say so. But I’d also say it’s senseless to blame this on business owners, because this is just how capitalism works! It’s not the person – it’s the system. The problem is that, economically speaking, workers and capitalists have opposing interests. What’s good for one side is bad for the other. If you’re a worker, you want high pay, good benefits, short hours, workplace safety and the freedom to work at your own pace. But for a capitalist – that’s not good. As a capitalist, all these things result in less profit for you. To maximize profit, you want your workers to work as fast as possible, as much as possible, as cheaply as possible. Basically, capitalists have an economic motive to make life for their workers harder and shittier. As you can imagine, this has a morally corrupting influence. I’m not saying that capitalists are bad people, but if you are a capitalist, you might stop caring about your workers’ wellbeing because their wellbeing stands in the way of your profits. And what about when capitalists do care about workers? Well, they tend to be less successful, and often go out of business. Nothing is more corrupting than a system that punishes those who care for others and rewards those who don’t. Now I am beautiful for Dear Leader. Dear Leader, do you think I am beautiful? [Marx] Makeup is bourgeois decadence. You bring shame upon your comrades. [Sad cello music] [Crying]
[Sad cello music] [Destiny] In capitalism you have a few big companies that can basically fund a whole bunch of climate change denialism and stuff like that. But in socialism, I would imagine what these companies would do is, these companies, kind of like unions, would all come together in order to use their bargaining power, their leverage on society, in the form of paying for advertisements, or influencing elections, or nominating politicians, that’s what they would do. So, how does Ben Burgis respond on this? Well, he does say that in socialism, we’d have more democratic power to stop global warming, but unless I misunderstood him, he seems to agree with you that socialism would have the same economic pressures as capitalism to destroy the environment. I have to completely disagree, and this comes down to the different visions of socialism that Ben and I have. Ben is of the social democrat tradition of socialists, and I’m more of the tradition of socialists that has historically been murdered by social democrats – not that I’m blaming Ben for that. [Loud chopping sounds] NO HARD FEELINGS, BEN. NONE AT ALL! (Laugh) No, for real, Ben, we good, still. I love you, fam. Ben’s vision of socialism, if I understand correctly, includes a private sector of worker owned co-operative businesses, which just like capitalist businesses, compete with each other for profit. Other socialists, including me, have a different vision of socialism. For starters, workers would not own their workplace. Instead, each workplace, and the means of production as a whole, would belong to everyone. That is to say, the wealth that we workers produce would belong to all people, and be used to advance the common good of all people. Another difference is we would not produce goods for the purpose of making profit. And this is key, because if you take away the profit motive, you take away the main motive for environmental destruction. Businesses don’t use environmentally sustainable methods, why? because those methods are usually less profitable. But take away the profit motive, you take away the problem. Businesses clear-cut forests, cover eco-systems in suburbs, mine coal and pump oil – all because it’s profitable. But take away the profit motive, you take away the problem. A next point you brought up was about coal co-operatives pushing against environmental reforms, because the coal workers would not want to lose their jobs. But this would not happen in socialism because workers would not depend on their job for a decent standard of living. In socialism, if you’re out of work, you still have your home, food, healthcare, everything you had when you were working, and free education to retrain for a new career. So, losing your job, eh, not a big deal. Now, I know all this brings up new questions, like, how the hell would an economic system function without the profit motive? I will be explaining this, but it has to wait for a future video. Sor-ry. (Lip synching)
♫ If I ever let you down ♫ ♫ I’m sorry ♫ ♫ If I ever made you cry ♫ ♫ I’m sorry ♫ ♫ ever made you cry ♫ ♫ ever made you cry ♫ ♫ ever made you cry ♫ ♫ cry ♫ ♫ cry ♫ (mock whining sound) “i’M kArL mArX, mAkEuP iS bOuRgEoIs dEcAdEnCe.” (sucking teeth sound) Bourgeois decadence? I’m’a bourgeois deck you upside the head. Fucking pretentious commie beard! [sad cello music] And now we come to my favorite topic: Stupid people. I just love talking about myself. I used to be smart, but then I did this too many times. [Destiny] There’s already what percentage of Americans that don’t even believe that climate change is real. [Destiny] I said multiple times like workers are dumb or whatever. I think in general like people seem to be like pretty clueless about issues. And this isn’t just workers, this is like all sorts of different people. Ok, so you’re concerned that too many people are ignorant, and that this will still be the case in socialism. I think Ben makes a really good point on this. [Ben Burgis] It’s not just that people sort of happen to form these views on their own. There is a very large and very profitable industry devoted to propagandizing them. I mean, you know, how much money does, you know, does ExxonMobil spend promoting the idea that this is a myth. But then, Destiny, you also make a good point: [Destiny] In this new economy that we’re talking about is like is all advertising banned? Because why wouldn’t like coal mining co-ops do the exact same type of advertising? True-say, Destiny, we’d be no better off than we are now, brainwashed by profit-seeking companies to the point that they might as well be controlling us through a chip in our brain! Aaggh! Aaaagggghh! Aaaaaaaagggghhhhhh! This is why the social democrat version of socialism is flawed. And it’s why we need an economic system where we no longer produce for profit. Profit needs to get the F up out the picture! Buh-bye! With no profit motive, there’s no economic motive to have any sort of advertising or fake news bullshit to spread lies about climate change. So we can expect the discourse in the media would get a lot more informative and accurate. Also, in socialism, we can pour way more funding into education than we do now. All the wealth that, in capitalism, is hoarded by the rich would instead be freed up to use for the common good of all humanity, which of course includes improving education. Another reason we’d have more funding for education is that in socialism, various industries that were necessary in capitalism would no longer be needed, like advertising, sales, finance, insurance, corporate law, patent law – to name just a few examples. This would free up workers to move into other industries, including education. [Lucky Black Cat] Dear Leader… Dear Leader… I have something for you… [Marx] What are you doing? No. No! Noooooooooo! Oh. Actually, that looks rather nice. Part 4: Can we have a strong economy? So strong. So very strong. Oh yes. Don’t fuck with this muscle! So, Ben made a good point about automation, or technology taking over human jobs. In capitalism, automation causes unemployment and desperation. But not in socialism. [Ben Burgis] If the workers were controlling the company, then they could just say, “Hey why don’t we each just work two hours instead of the eight hours that we used to? And since we’re getting just as much produced then, you know, we could all still earn what we did before.” Makes sense – but for you, Destiny, it raised a concern. [Destiny] Is it realistic that our economy could thrive in a global economy when all of our workers are working like one or two hours a day? So, I get your concern, I do. We don’t want to stagnate, and we don’t want our economy to become weak, like some sort of … cat-ear-wearing soy-girl. [loud “thud”] It gets tiring after a while. But look, if you hear me out, I think you’ll agree that there’s nothing to worry about. Trust me, brejin. Ok, so, imagine a socialist society where our work hours are short. We have more free time and free education at any age – and not just academic education, but free training in any skill, trade or profession. This combination of free time and free education could lead to a renaissance of discovery, creativity, and advancement in every field, from science and technology to art and entertainment. It could be freaking awesome, yo! You might be thinking, “Well, I don’t know. All this innovation and advancement takes a lot of work, and why would people bother when they can just work two hours a day, instead?” One thing that’s nearly universal among human beings is our desire for life to have a sense of meaning and purpose. We don’t like too much idleness, or to feel like we don’t contribute anything. It gets boring, you feel empty, it hurts your self-esteem. I think most people will find it boring to work so little. They’ll want something more out of life, and will be eager to develop and strengthen their skills and talents, and to use those talents in a way they find meaningful, to experience that sense of pride, passion, and purpose that comes when you contribute something you feel is important. Ok, so let’s reconsider your concern: You want a strong economy that spurs innovation and advancement, and you think that compared to capitalism, socialism can’t compete. But what if it’s the other way around? Stephen Jay Gould said: In capitalism, many people are deprived of a good education, and so the talents they could have offered the world are not able to develop. In capitalism, many children grow up poor and malnourished, and this does serious harm to their intellectual development, which robs society of their potential. Also in capitalism, people’s freedom to innovate is blocked by patents. People avoid inventing anything that improves upon a previous invention, because doing that can get them sued for patent violation. And also in capitalism, because companies are in competition, experts and innovators working for different companies are forbidden to share their knowledge and research with each other. This slows our advancement in all kinds of things, even life or death issues like finding cures for disease. In socialism, we can avoid all of this bullshit, because we can provide free, high quality education to everyone, eliminate poverty, and put an end to the competition for profit that leads to patents and knowledge hoarding. With these obstacles cleared away, economic advancement will get a big-ass turbo-charged boost. So, it seems safe to say that socialism can provide us a strong, thriving economy. But what if people decide to only work two hours a day – would that be so bad? Remember, we’re not talking about a situation where our economic output declines. We’re producing as much as ever, but thanks to automation, we’ve cut down our work hours. This of course would free up our time to pursue hobbies or things like sports art music travelling learning spending time with loved ones and various activities that enhance our enjoyment of life. Sure, this would come at the expense of expanding economic production, but so what? Economic production is just a means to an end, and that end is human wellbeing. Our goal should not be to maximize production, but to maximize our wellbeing. At times, economic growth can serve that purpose, but at other times, we should sacrifice some growth for the sake of enhancing our wellbeing in other ways. With the economy, as with other things, what matters is not size, but how much it satisfies. [Marx] Lucky Black Cat can’t satisfy you like I can, Destiny. No one can. Hey, everyone! I hope you don’t mind me asking you for a favor but I don’t know if Destiny will actually see this video, or even find out it exists. So if you could, please, tweet this video to him @ModalSevenths m, o, d, a, l,
s, e, v, e, n, t, h, s…? Yeah. And hey, maybe we can actually get Destiny to watch this! And it would also be really cool if we could get Ben Burgis and The Serfs to watch it, too. So I put everyone’s contact info down in the description, and if you can spare a minute, maybe send them the link, too. That would be so great. I also want to say, if you liked or commented on my last video, or you subscribed, or hit that bell, you truly touched my heart and you filled me with hope, and for that I am — I really owe you a big thank you. (UPDATE: All of them watched the video! 🙂
No need to contact them!)




Comments
  1. Edit: Destiny, Ben Burgis and The Serfs have all watched the video now, so no need to contact them. Thank you!

    You might think it’s inconsistent that I call myself socialist in this video while in my last video I call myself libertarian-communist. However, I’d argue that communism falls under the wider umbrella of socialism (an economic system with socially owned means of production).

    Also, I try not to get hung up on labels, and am comfortable calling myself a libertarian-communist, libertarian-socialist, anarchist, communist, socialist, and perhaps other terms, too! So don’t be surprised if I bounce back and forth between different labels! I’m thinking of sticking with libertarian-socialist, though, since many people have very negative misunderstandings of communism, and I don’t want to scare people off before they hear what I have to say.

    Let me know if the audio was loud enough this time!

    Credit to ContraPoints for inspiring the skit with Marx.

    Thank you to everyone who liked or commented on this video, or who subscribed or hit the bell, or who SHARED it (I can’t believe I forgot to mention that one in the video)! And thanks for watching! Have a great day, everyone.

  2. Comment to boost this awesome channel in the algorithm (also shared it on r/breadtube hope that helps you).

  3. I really like your style of making videos! Your humour is a bit quirky, just like mine.
    I would recommend though getting better equipment (maybe get a tripod for your phone if it has a high video quality and get a cheap clip microphone). And if I may give more constructive criticism: you actually can get a lot of quality when rendering a video. Like the format of the video (for about half of the video) could be fixed easily. You can get some good software for a great price. Especially with a 5 finger discount (if you know what I mean ;)). A seperate mic is highly recommendable because even if it's cheap (like 10 $) usually improves the sound and you have less struggle with the loudness of the video.
    I'm by far no expert but I know a thing or two about videomaking and that's at least my take on it.

    Btw I know one is not supposed to ask but I really can't tell: which broad range of age are you? Because from all I know you could be in your mid 20s or a young looking mid 40s. And I'm just a very curious person and I really have problems guessing your age 😀

  4. This is good shit. Destiny got laminated in this debate. LBC, do you like to do live debates or do you only do scripted content like most breadtubers.

  5. Sharp responses, and a highly entertaining format. Great video! One thing though: not sure if it's a problem with my player but your video seemed slightly out of sync from the audio in places. Looking forward to seeing more!

    ~Melody

  6. You're doing the world a solid, LuckyBlackCat. I love the positive message of what a socialist society would bring.

  7. You did it again!👌👍
    Thank you!
    Think about all the time spent working to earn money to buy time-saving devices…

  8. The connection between right wing propaganda and so many people being uneducated is something I’ve been noticing a lot recently. People aren’t just stupid. There’s a literal force keeping people stupid. Without it they would have the freedom to actually learn

  9. Your style was weird to me at first. But you've grown on me. Lifetime subscriber gained. Please keep the same lightheartedness moving forward. A lot of us leftists usually fall into the doom and gloom when it comes to discussing late stage capitalism, imperialism and the necessity of socialism. Love the music. Looking forward to the next one.

  10. glad you addressed Ben's weird confusing defense of socialism. His version basically sounds like capitalism still except workers run the businesses who c ompete against each for… money? God, Ben you really need a better imagination…

  11. I loved it! It’s so heartening to see these episodes finally produced. One thing I would add to point 4, the concern about a robust economy, is that capitalism, with its singleminded drive for profit, is actually profoundly wasteful and inefficient at doing much of anything other than turning a profit for capitalists. In this manner I would actually reject the very premise of Destiny’s question. What does he mean by “strength” and “innovation” in a context where so much of the world’s productive capacity is squandered through planned obsolescence or frivolous products, produced through environmentally unsound techniques, that serve no reasonable social good? Well-trained and educated minds pour their creativity into making the next Angry Birds, or KFC Cheeto burgers, or cars designed to break after a certain mileage, while millions are malnourished and the world burns. That’s all well and good for GDP and stocks, but how is that strong or innovative by any measure that incorporates the advancement of global human potential or ecological sanity? Rather, capitalism stands as both a betrayal of the vision for a strong and progressive human society it’s advocates once, long ago, used to justify its existence, and a great barrier to harnessing the potential of scientific innovation because anything other than profit generation is beyond the logic of the system. What a waste! A democratically planned economy (a key element of my vision of socialism) would be largely free of such perverse distortions and disastrous contradictions and any honest socio-economic analysis will take this as given. The real question is how to get there before global warming or nuclear war render the questions moot?

  12. This video is okay but I wish you'd ease up on the jokes and get a bit more substancive with your critiques. The bits were funny at first, but at least for me you spent way to much of the video on them and it got old fast.

    You make good points with your critiques, but ultimately they could be summed up in a couple paragraphs Reddit comment. Not really enough to convince someone like Destiny.

  13. Ben and Destiny seemed to be discussing market socialism rather than an economy where production is based on use-values rather than exchange-values.

  14. Hey Lucky, you have a pretty unique voice for this thing. The very concept of anti-capitalism scares the shit out of people, and you seem to make revolutionary ideas accessible and interesting for anyone with even a slightly open mind. More impressive to me personally is it comes across really effortless too. I know a lot of that is hard work and a deep understanding of the subject matter, but I respect it a great deal and it's primarily what makes you one of the brightest new voices on breadtube. Hope Destiny notices you, Senpai. Can't wait for your next one.

  15. Is this what happens when blessed leader Marx is seperated from comrade Engals?

    Oh you covered whether you where a rosa killer or not thank goodness you will be spared their fate!

    Also like the education system serves the class dictatorship of course it keeps the proletariat stunted…

  16. Enjoyed your 2nd video as well, though few points i would debate (though certainly not now because i'm exhausted!) Look forward to more!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *